Janis Joplin or Leontyne Price
There is an old saying among horse-betting enthusiasts: “You bets your money and you takes your choice.”
How else can it be when you compare the great diva, Leontyne Price, with the gut-wrenching singing of the queen of psychedelic drugs, Janis Joplin?
As for another old saying, “There is no accounting for taste,” that is plainly false and most likely the best way to make sense of it is to understand it as “There is no way to justify taste.” Let’s go with that.
Janis was born to middle class parents but was always a misfit. Her wild ways were too much for her high school mates and she was deeply into the use of drugs as a teenager. Nevertheless, she tried a brief period of studiousness when she was a sociology major in college. It just didn’t take, and in short order she put that behind her and became the legend in her own time, dying young at age 27. Surprisingly, she is ranked only as the 28th greatest singer of all time by Rolling Stone magazine.
To the casual ear, her voice is hopelessly out of control and usually off key. But listen closely and you will notice that she is the master of her vocal chords and always knows where she wants the next note to land. Her style is unique and loved by rock fans but for those who, like me, were raised on classical singing, it takes a bit of work to grasp her genius. Here is a clip of her singing the superb classic, Summertime, from the opera Porgy and Bess.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzNEgcqWDG4
Price’s upbringing was very different. She was the daughter of dirt-poor black folk in Mississippi who early on recognized the extraordinary talent of their daughter and sacrificed to give her the best musical education. Even with it, she did not rise to stardom until she was about the same age as Joplin was when the latter died of an overdose of heroin combined with plenty of alcohol.
Of Price’s singing, it is good to know that the great trumpeter, Miles Davis, had this to say: “I have always been one of her fans because in my opinion she is the greatest female singer ever, the greatest opera singer ever. She could hit anything with her voice. Leontyne’s so good it’s scary. … I love the way she sings Tosca. I wore out her recording of that, wore out two sets.”
Here is Price’s version of Summertime. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMCw_FjSQuQ